Home > On the horizon: Spot opportunities and trends > Don’t expect electric cars to substitute motor cars like-for-like

Don’t expect electric cars to substitute motor cars like-for-like

Disruptive innovations often combine a changes on several dimensions: product, consumer experience, market segment, business model. The emblematic example remains the iPod, which would not have met its phenomenal success if it had not been associated with the business model change that iTunes brought to the music distribution industry. Like-for-like substitution of the old product by the new product, everything else being equal, is rarely a recipe for breakthrough innovation.

Take the electric car. The current focus of the auto industry is to increase battery autonomy and drastcially reduce recharging time in order to mimic the experience that the motorist currently gets when driving long distances refuelling along the way in a few minutes. This is almost certainly a lost cause!

The cost/performance benefits of the combustion engine and associated equipment and infrastructure are such that it is unlikely they will be beaten any time soon by an alternative technology in a head-on confrontation.

Now, imagine combining the current state of the art in electric car technology with a different business model and consumer experience.

For short distances (under 160km/day or 100miles/day), which represent the vast majority of car usage, the current level of performance of the electric engine is already technically sufficient. Combining it with a rental scheme model such as the Autolib scheme or even an individual monthly rental scheme could create a breakthrough in the rate of adoption of the new technology. It is likely that we will see a lot of such schemes coming from traditional auto manufacturers as they launch their range of electric vehicles in the coming months and years.

For long distances, what if the existing highspeed railway network could be harnessed to create a multi-modal transport experience for individuals on a routine basis? You would drive your electric car on a short distance from your home to a nearby train terminal, where you would board both car and passengers on a highspeed train that would take you in a faster, safer and more relaxing way to a terminal close to your destination while recharging your car for the last leg of the journey to your destination point.

Is it thinkable? Well, multi-modal transport already exists for commercial goods transport: a truck takes a container from the plant to the nearby train station, a train takes the container on a long distance, another truck picks it up from the arrival train station and takes it to its final delivery point nearby. The Channel Tunnel between France and the UK is another example of a multi-modal operation both for trucks and passenger cars (see picture). Another such tunnel is currently being built under the Swiss Alps. And obviously, the business of car ferries has been in existence for a number of decades…

So, what needs to happen?  Here is a short list to get started. Please use the comment box to brainstorm other ideas!

  • Adapt existing high-speed train carriages to take small electric vehicles on board. Develop electric vehicles with the adequate width to fit in those carriages (which probably means getting rid of ‘Chelsea tractors’).
  • Pick the longest/busiest route in a given country and build a small boarding terminal for cars at each end.
  • Turn cars into an entertainment centres with rotating seats to face each other for a chat, a family game, a lunch; develop a car-cinema option on the windscreen.
  • Get rid of the macho communication about driving our car like James Bond or race pilots (and for those who really miss it too badly, we can create a video game that can be played at the wheel while the car is on board the train!)

Please use the comment box to brainstorm other ideas and add to the list!

  1. January 15, 2011 at 04:44

    I wrote on this myself earlier today, and it was a pleasure to read your view on it innovtoday. – cars2scrap.

  2. March 18, 2012 at 15:08

    Daily when I take the boat to cross the river to get to work, the boats take on them the small cars that are widely used in Holland, which I have not quite seen elsewhere.

    Reading your idea above, it is not impossible if electric cars are also adapted to the sizes that fit as a means for short travel than long distances.

    The rental scheme you suggested made me think of the train and ride scheme infamous here. Such combinations could be attractive to daily commuters who instead of cycling can drive their smart electric cars out – avoiding rain, bad weather and dress ‘smart’-ly to work! During economic crisis times as we are in, personal cost-saving is a big thing for individuals and making use of that could also create an opportunity.

  1. January 10, 2011 at 17:19
  2. June 23, 2011 at 11:17
  3. January 7, 2012 at 10:02
  4. December 12, 2012 at 09:04
  5. January 4, 2013 at 17:01
  6. May 21, 2014 at 19:45

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: